Toilet Repair vs. Replacement & When to Call a Professional Plumber

Published Date: October 15th, 2024 | Category: Plumbing Repair

Toilets are one of the most frequently used fixtures in a home, and when they malfunction, it can be both inconvenient and frustrating. While some minor toilet issues can be resolved with simple DIY fixes, others require professional expertise. If you’re dealing with a troublesome toilet, you might be wondering whether to repair the problem or replace the fixture entirely. Luckily, All Ways Drains is available to help with toilet repair in White Bear Lake, and we can help you determine when repairs just won’t cut it.

plumber with pipes and toilet in background

Common Toilet Problems That Can Be Repaired

Many toilet issues are relatively simple to repair and don’t require a complete replacement. Here are a few common problems that can often be fixed:

  1. Running Toilet
    A running toilet is one of the most common issues homeowners face. This is usually caused by a faulty flapper valve, a broken fill valve or improper float settings. In most cases, these components can be easily replaced, restoring the toilet to proper working order.
  2. Weak Flushing
    If your toilet isn’t flushing as powerfully as it should, it could be due to a clog in the trap, issues with the fill valve or low water levels in the tank. Often, adjusting the water level or cleaning out minor blockages can improve the flush, eliminating the need for replacement.
  3. Leaky Toilet
    Water leaks are often caused by worn-out seals or gaskets, which can lead to water pooling at the base of the toilet or inside the tank. Replacing these seals is typically a straightforward repair. However, if the toilet itself is cracked, replacement may be necessary.
  4. Clogs
    Clogged toilets are frustrating, but they don’t always mean you need a new one. Many clogs can be cleared with a plunger or plumbing snake, and if they occur frequently, it could indicate a deeper issue with the plumbing that can be addressed without replacing the entire fixture.

When to Consider Replacing Your Toilet

While repairs are often sufficient, there are some situations where it makes more sense to replace your toilet altogether. Here are a few instances where replacement is likely the best option:

  1. Frequent Repairs
    If your toilet requires constant repairs, it’s probably time to consider a replacement. The cost of multiple repairs can add up quickly, and at a certain point, it becomes more cost-effective to invest in a new, reliable toilet.
  2. Cracked Toilet Bowl or Tank
    A crack in the porcelain bowl or tank can lead to serious water damage in your bathroom. While small cracks might not cause immediate issues, they can worsen over time, leading to leaks. In most cases, replacing the toilet is the safest and most effective solution for preventing future problems.
  3. Outdated or Inefficient Toilet
    Older toilets, especially those installed before the 1990s, use significantly more water than modern, low-flow models. If you’re still using an older toilet, replacing it with a newer, more efficient model can save water and reduce your utility bills. Plus, modern toilets often have better flushing technology, reducing the chances of clogs and other issues.
  4. Severe Mineral Buildup
    In areas with hard water, mineral deposits can build up inside the toilet’s pipes and jets, reducing its efficiency over time. While minor buildup can sometimes be cleaned, severe cases may require a replacement to restore proper function.

When to Call a Professional

While some toilet repairs are manageable for homeowners, others require the expertise of a professional plumber. If you’re dealing with persistent issues, significant leaks or are unsure whether your toilet needs repair or replacement, calling a professional like All Ways Drains is the best course of action.

We can quickly assess the problem, provide recommendations and complete the repair or replacement efficiently, saving you time and frustration. Additionally, a professional plumber can help you choose the right replacement toilet if needed, ensuring it meets your home’s water efficiency standards and provides reliable performance for years to come.

Deciding between repairing or replacing a toilet depends on the severity of the issue, the age of the fixture and the frequency of repairs. While minor problems can often be fixed, frequent repairs or significant damage may warrant a replacement. For expert advice and toilet repair services, contact All Ways Drains. Our professional plumbers will help you make the best decision for your home, ensuring your toilet is functioning properly and efficiently. Call us today at 612-922-9422 or request a free estimate! Our emergency plumber is available 24/7, 365 days a year.